MFN members and others win suit against dirty BNSF railyard and protect community health

Photo: East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice

This week a California Superior Court judge handed the community a huge victory when he ruled that the Environmental Impact Study for a huge BNSF Intermodal Railyard was flawed, reversed project approvals, and ordered a halt to construction-related activities.

His groundbreaking ruling was in response to a lawsuit filed by Moving Forward Network members East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice (EYCEJ), Coalition for a Safe Environment (CFASE), and the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), as well as the City of Long Beach, the school district, and others.

SCIG Map, Source: LA Streetsblog

The BNSF Southern California Intermodal Gateway (SCIG), which BNSF planned to locate next to residences, schools, and day care centers, was to handle 2.8 million containers of goods annually from the Ports of Long Beach and Los Angeles.  It would have generated over 2 million diesel truck trips a year and enormous levels of dangerous diesel exhaust pollution.

When he filed suit, David Pettit, senior NRDC attorney, said “The SCIG project typifies environmental racism. This project can be built away from where people live and children go to school, but the City of Los Angeles wants to put it in a low-income minority neighborhood because they think they can get away with it.”

 

The lawsuit followed years of effort by community and environmental organizations to convince BNSF not to increase their profits at the expense of residents’ health.

While the BNSF could have proposed to move freight from the ports to the SCIG using Zero and Near-Zero Emissions technology, they choose not to.  Will they learn from their defeat, and stop polluting neighborhoods and damaging people’s health, as the community has repeatedly demanded?

For more information, see the resources below:

News Articles

Court Rejects SCIG EIR, Random Lengths

Court deals setback to Port of L.A. rail yard planned near poor neighborhoods,  LA Times

Long Beach wins lawsuit over $500 million rail yard plan for Port of Los Angeles, Los Angeles Daily News

Southern California International Gateway Railyard Found to Have Faulty Environmental Impact Report, Long Beach Post

Judge Backs City of Long Beach in Rail Yard Project Suit; Port of LA & BNSF Sent Back to Drawing Board, Streetsblog LA

The Lawsuit

Superior Court of the State of California Opinion and Order

Southern California International Gateway Project Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR), Port of Los Angeles

Zero and Near-Zero Emissions Freight Transportation

Sustainable Freight – Pathways to Zero and Near-Zero Emissions, California Air Resources Board

MOVING CALIFORNIA FORWARD, Zero and Low-Emissions Freight Pathways, California Cleaner Freight Coalition

National Freight Pathways – Moving Toward a Cleaner System to Reduce Emissions, Improve Air Quality, and Create Healthier Communities, NRDC

Recent Blog Posts

Success stories show why weakening the National Environmental Policy Act would harm America

Share Tweet Share +1 RedditThe National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) requires that government agencies understand the environmental, health, and other impacts of their actions before they spend our tax dollars, and that the American public be involved and informed. NEPA is designed to ensure that agencies analyze risks and alternatives, and make decisions based on the facts. NEPA […]

Read More

West Oakland Environmental Indicators Project research reveals dangerous pollution hotspots

Share Tweet Share +1 RedditAs the Moving Forward Network members that do air pollution monitoring know from on-the-ground experience, EPA regulatory air monitors may show an area to have low levels of particulate matter from diesel exhaust and other air pollution when in fact, nearby hot spots can have high and dangerous levls of air […]

Read More

New study adds more evidence that diesel exhaust can damage your heart

Share Tweet Share +1 RedditImage: Northwestern University Even as the current U.S. presidential administration is slashing regulations and funding for reducing air pollution and protecting public health, a new English study found that long-term exposure to diesel exhaust particulate matter at levels far below EPA standards can cause enlargement of the heart, which is associated […]

Read More

Comite Civico and Loma Linda University Medical Center train and empower students to be citizen scientists and monitor air pollution

Share Tweet Share +1 RedditThe Brawley, California community organization Comite Civico Del Valle has tremendous accomplishments under its belt, including installation of a very robust set of fixed air pollution monitors throughout the region, and establishment of the IVAN environmental reporting system, used by residents in the Imperial Valley and communities across the state. Working with long-time […]

Read More